Publications
Accounting

Third-Quarter Close: Three Variances Owners Should Investigate

A third-quarter close should do more than confirm that transactions were entered. It should explain why the business is ahead of or behind plan and what management will change before year-end.

Revenue quality

Separate price, volume and timing. Revenue may exceed budget because work was completed early, because prices improved or because one customer produced an unusual order. Those explanations have different implications for the fourth quarter. Reconcile unbilled work, deferred revenue and large credit notes before drawing conclusions.

Gross margin

Compare margin by service line, product or customer where the records allow it. A company can grow revenue while losing economic ground through overtime, input costs, discounts or poor job estimates. Investigate both percentage and dollar variances; a small percentage change on a large revenue base can materially affect cash.

Working capital

Review receivable days, overdue balances, inventory turns, work in progress and supplier terms. Profit may look stable while more cash becomes trapped in operations. The CRA’s record-keeping guidance reinforces the need for source documents and reliable electronic records, but management reporting should also make those records useful for decisions.

Assign each material variance an owner, a corrective action and a date for review. The close becomes valuable when it changes a forecast or an operating decision.

Put the issue into numbers

If revenue is 8% above budget but gross margin dollars are unchanged, the company may be winning more low-margin work or using discounts to maintain volume. If receivable days also rise, growth is using cash without improving returns. That combination deserves action before celebrating the top-line variance.

What to document

Keep a short variance log showing amount, cause, owner, corrective action and next review date. Link material items to customer, job or product reports so the explanation can be tested rather than repeated from memory.

Questions for the advisory team

  • Which revenue variance is repeatable and which is timing?
  • Where did margin change most, and what caused it?
  • Which working-capital item creates the greatest fourth-quarter cash risk?

This article provides general information only. Tax, legal, financing and investment decisions should reflect your records and circumstances.