Planned publication date: March 25, 2024. Updated March 28, 2024.
In the final week before the 2023 trust-filing deadline, many owners and families were trying to determine whether a nominee or title-holding arrangement was a bare trust. The immediate filing position changed on March 28, but the underlying ownership questions remained important.
Why the issue reached ordinary business arrangements
A bare trust can arise where one person holds legal title and acts only on the direction of the beneficial owner. Possible examples included real estate registered in another name, nominee corporations, joint accounts and property held for administrative convenience. Whether a trust exists depends on the legal rights and facts—not the label used by the parties.
Before March 28, the expanded reporting rules led many taxpayers to assess whether a 2023 T3 return and Schedule 15 were required even if the arrangement had little or no income.
CRA relief changed the immediate filing decision
On March 28, 2024, the CRA announced that bare trusts would not be required to file a T3 return and Schedule 15 for the 2023 taxation year unless the CRA made a direct request. The announcement came shortly before the deadline, which for most calendar-year trusts was treated as April 2, 2024 because March 30 fell on a weekend.
The relief applied to bare trusts for that year. It did not mean every trust was exempt, and it did not determine whether a legal trust relationship existed.
Keep the records already gathered
Document the registered owner, beneficial owner, property involved, acquisition date, source of funds and authority to make decisions. Retain agreements, closing documents, bank records and correspondence supporting the arrangement.
These records can affect income attribution, reporting of a sale, principal-residence analysis, corporate balances, estate administration and future filing obligations. If legal and accounting records describe ownership differently, resolve the discrepancy.
Separate legal analysis from filing administration
Legal counsel may need to determine the ownership relationship and whether a trust exists. The accountant can then assess tax reporting using that conclusion. Filing a return—or relying on relief—should not substitute for understanding who owns the property.
A record can matter even when no return is filed
Suppose an individual holds title to real property on behalf of a corporation. CRA’s relief may remove the 2023 bare-trust return requirement, but the arrangement can still affect who reports rental income, who records the asset and liability, and how a future sale is documented. Similar questions arise where an adult child is on a parent’s bank or investment account only for convenience.
A short ownership memorandum prepared while the facts are fresh can record the parties’ intention, source of funds, decision-making authority and reporting position. It should agree with legal documents and tax filings. If it does not, the discrepancy deserves attention before a transaction or estate event forces the issue.
Questions for the advisory team
- Which arrangements may involve different legal and beneficial owners?
- Is the arrangement truly a bare trust, another type of trust, or not a trust?
- Are ownership records sufficient if the CRA later requests information?
This article provides general information reflecting CRA’s March 28, 2024 administrative relief. Trust and ownership questions require fact-specific legal and tax review.
