Planned publication date: January 15, 2024.
The Bank of Canada’s fourth-quarter 2023 Business Outlook Survey described an economy in which demand was softening, competitive pressure was increasing and labour shortages were becoming less intense. For an owner-managed business, the useful question was not whether the survey sounded optimistic or pessimistic. It was which assumptions in the 2024 plan needed testing.
Demand deserved a more conservative forecast
The January 15, 2024 survey reported that higher interest rates were restraining spending and that firms expected sales growth to remain weak. This did not mean every business would decline. It did mean that a budget relying on effortless volume growth warranted scrutiny.
Owners could separate committed revenue from pipeline opportunities, compare expected orders with the prior year and identify customers most sensitive to financing costs. A base case, downside case and recovery case are more useful than a single precise forecast.
Pricing pressure was changing, not disappearing
Firms reported renewed competitive pressure and slower growth in output prices. At the same time, wage growth was expected to ease only gradually. That combination can compress margins: selling prices become harder to raise while payroll costs remain sticky.
A practical response is to calculate contribution margin by service, product line or customer group. If prices cannot move, the owner needs to know whether scheduling, purchasing, delivery or service mix can protect the margin. Across-the-board cost cutting can damage the parts of the business that still produce strong returns.
Labour planning could become more selective
Easing labour shortages created an opportunity to improve hiring discipline. Rather than filling every vacancy automatically, owners could ask which roles remove a genuine capacity constraint, improve collections, shorten delivery time or support higher-value work.
Compensation planning still mattered because wage growth remained elevated. A hiring decision should include salary, payroll costs, benefits, onboarding time and the working capital required before the new employee contributes to collections.
Borrowing decisions needed room for delay
With interest rates still restrictive, capital spending and expansion plans needed to work under realistic borrowing costs. Compare debt service with incremental cash flow, not accounting profit alone. Test whether the investment remains manageable if demand arrives later than expected or the loan renews at an unfavourable rate.
A practical planning example
Suppose a service company’s 2024 budget assumes revenue will rise 10%, selling prices will rise 5% and payroll will rise 8%. The survey’s combination of soft demand, greater competition and persistent wage growth suggests testing a less comfortable case: no volume growth, only a 2% price increase and the full payroll increase.
That scenario may reveal that a planned hire is affordable only if receivables remain within target or if lower-margin work is repriced. The point is not to adopt the downside case as a forecast. It is to identify which early indicators—quoted work, utilization, order volume, customer concentration and collection days—would tell management that the original plan needs adjustment.
Questions for the advisory team
- Which revenue assumptions depend most heavily on stronger customer demand?
- Where are wages or input costs rising faster than selling prices?
- Which planned investments remain worthwhile under a slower-growth scenario?
This article provides general information based on conditions reported on January 15, 2024. Business and financing decisions should reflect current facts and the company’s circumstances.
